Actually, I was reading through your Four tag a bit while I watched and it was like 'oh good, we agree on nothing.' Except Leela. Leela is amazing. I kept reading anyway tho because you're entertaining and I like disagreeing with people.
And the Nimons are pretty great.
But, like, Four got a lobotomy between seasons 15 and 16 or something. Which is sad because I want to like funny lighthearted episodes! And Romana! I was complaining to Elisi because Douglas Adams is in charge and the companion is a mega-smart, quippy lady who can take the Doctor down a peg and I hate everything, what is wrong with me?!?!!
Mostly I have a lot of conflicting feelings about every season of Four. Because Four is the best from about seasons 13-15 (he kinda reminds me of Twelve round about season nine? I always thought Four was mostly just spacey and weird and a bit rude, but this one has depth and it was very exciting!) and Sarah is pretty great as soon as you get her away from Harry, but the Hinchcliffe horror thing is dull, really. Leela fills me with unmitigated squee but there's a lot of dud episodes in her seasons and so help me, K9 makes me want to murder things. I want to like Romana and Four'n'Romana so much more than I do, expect in Shada and season 18 I do rather love them? And I want to like funny, lighthearted, caper-y Doctor Who so much more than I do, except City of Death, and Shada actually are excellent and I wish Adams had managed to write more episodes. Also Ribos Operation was good fun. And then season 18 is the first time that the writing has really been working for me AND THEY FINALLY KILLED K9 THANK YOU and Four is a bit better again, but he is still basically phoning it in.
^^^ No idea if all of that is just par for the course with Classic Who or if Four is special or if I am weird, but there it is.
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
(no subject)
Date: 8 Dec 2018 12:16 pm (UTC)Actually, I was reading through your Four tag a bit while I watched and it was like 'oh good, we agree on nothing.' Except Leela. Leela is amazing. I kept reading anyway tho because you're entertaining and I like disagreeing with people.
And the Nimons are pretty great.
But, like, Four got a lobotomy between seasons 15 and 16 or something. Which is sad because I want to like funny lighthearted episodes! And Romana! I was complaining to Elisi because Douglas Adams is in charge and the companion is a mega-smart, quippy lady who can take the Doctor down a peg and I hate everything, what is wrong with me?!?!!
Mostly I have a lot of conflicting feelings about every season of Four. Because Four is the best from about seasons 13-15 (he kinda reminds me of Twelve round about season nine? I always thought Four was mostly just spacey and weird and a bit rude, but this one has depth and it was very exciting!) and Sarah is pretty great as soon as you get her away from Harry, but the Hinchcliffe horror thing is dull, really. Leela fills me with unmitigated squee but there's a lot of dud episodes in her seasons and so help me, K9 makes me want to murder things. I want to like Romana and Four'n'Romana so much more than I do, expect in Shada and season 18 I do rather love them? And I want to like funny, lighthearted, caper-y Doctor Who so much more than I do, except City of Death, and Shada actually are excellent and I wish Adams had managed to write more episodes. Also Ribos Operation was good fun. And then season 18 is the first time that the writing has really been working for me AND THEY FINALLY KILLED K9 THANK YOU and Four is a bit better again, but he is still basically phoning it in.
^^^ No idea if all of that is just par for the course with Classic Who or if Four is special or if I am weird, but there it is.