Sorry for the very late reply to this--sometimes I loose comments in my inbox!
I have to agree with you about River regenerating--it seems like it's probably a step too far. And while the show was certainly very leading in the way it suggested regenerating girl might be River, it never did anything to say that that must be the case--we were most definitely "in the Doctors head" for those flashbacks, seeing that he was making a possible connection.
I think after AGMGTW, to me it seems likely that regenerating girl is River but by no means certain. I'm definitely not letting go of this theory. And even if regenerating girl is River, I think AGMGTW did a lot to strengthen the general argument for Doctor/River kids, even if she's not one herself.
no subject
I have to agree with you about River regenerating--it seems like it's probably a step too far. And while the show was certainly very leading in the way it suggested regenerating girl might be River, it never did anything to say that that must be the case--we were most definitely "in the Doctors head" for those flashbacks, seeing that he was making a possible connection.
I think after AGMGTW, to me it seems likely that regenerating girl is River but by no means certain. I'm definitely not letting go of this theory. And even if regenerating girl is River, I think AGMGTW did a lot to strengthen the general argument for Doctor/River kids, even if she's not one herself.